Building the Complaint File: Evidence, Limitation and Filing in Kolkata
A consumer complaint is deceptively simple to draft and surprisingly easy to lose. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 is a summary remedy, and the commissions expect a compact, documented narrative: what you bought, what was promised, what went wrong, what you asked for and how it was refused. Complaints that read as an outpouring of grievance, without a dated paper trail, tend to be met with a request for evidence and then with dismissal for want of proof of deficiency.
The Document Set
- Invoice, receipt or booking confirmation, showing the date, the amount and the identity of the opposite party.
- The promise: brochure, quotation, warranty card, policy document, advertisement, or the listing page as it appeared on the date of purchase.
- Proof of payment: bank statement, card statement, UPI record or cheque.
- The complaint trail: emails, written complaints, call-centre ticket numbers, and the opposite party's replies.
- Evidence of loss: repair estimates, medical records, photographs, valuation reports, or the cost of alternative arrangements.
- The legal notice and its postal proof, where notice was given.
- For builder matters, the agreement to sell, the allotment letter, the payment schedule and the occupation certificate status.
- Identity and address proof of the complainant, and the complaint fee.
Timing and Forum
| Item | Position under the 2019 Act |
|---|---|
| Limitation | Two years from the date of the cause of action; delay can be condoned on a written application showing sufficient cause |
| District Commission | Value of goods or services and compensation up to ₹50 lakh |
| State Commission | Above ₹50 lakh and up to ₹2 crore; sits in Kolkata and hears appeals from district commissions |
| National Commission | Above ₹2 crore, and appeals from state commissions |
| Filing mode | Online through the e-Daakhil portal, or physically before the commission having territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction |
Territorial jurisdiction lies where the opposite party carries on business, where the complainant resides or works, or where the cause of action arose. For a Kolkata consumer dealing with an out-of-state e-commerce entity, the residence ground is usually the practical route, and the complaint must plead it expressly.
Drafting Errors That Cost Compensation
- Claiming a round figure without a basis. Compensation is granted on proof. A claim of a large amount with no computation invites a token award.
- Not pleading "deficiency in service" or "unfair trade practice" in the statutory language. The commission decides within the framework of the Act; the pleading must engage it.
- Suing the wrong entity. The manufacturer, the dealer, the builder and the service provider are distinct opposite parties, and a complaint against the wrong one is dismissed at the threshold.
- Ignoring the arbitration clause. A clause in the agreement does not oust consumer jurisdiction, but the objection will be raised and must be answered.
- Filing after two years. The limitation is short and the condonation application needs reasons, not apologies.
On procedure, the commission may refer the dispute to mediation under Section 37 of the Act, and a mediated settlement is enforceable. Where the opposite party fails to appear despite service, the complaint proceeds ex parte. Execution of an awarded amount is by application to the same commission, which can attach property and, in some cases, order imprisonment for non-compliance.
Building a consumer complaint that survives the first hearing
A consumer complaint is usually decided on documents, so assemble them before drafting rather than after. The invoice or receipt, the warranty or contract, the written complaint you made to the seller or service provider, their reply or silence, and any photographs or inspection report together form the factual base. The Forum will want to see that you gave the other side an opportunity to put things right before you approached it.
State the defect, the loss and the relief you want in concrete terms. Vague claims about inconvenience are hard to quantify, whereas a claim for replacement, refund with interest, or the cost of repair is something the Forum can actually award. Keep your claim within the limit of the Forum you choose, and be consistent about the timeline you assert, since a date that shifts between the notice and the complaint invites an adjournment.