When the forum is the problem: transfer of cases in West Bengal
A transfer petition is what a litigant reaches for when the case itself is defensible but the court hearing it is not workable. The usual triggers are distance, cost, a witness who cannot travel, two proceedings between the same parties in different districts, or a genuine apprehension that a fair hearing will not be had in a particular court or before a particular presiding officer. It is not an appeal and it is not a review; nobody is asking the higher court to decide who is right. The only question is where the dispute should be tried.
In Kolkata practice, transfer work falls into three broad groups. Matrimonial matters, where a wife settled in Kolkata is fighting a divorce or restitution case filed in a distant district, are the largest group. Criminal matters, particularly complaints under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code or the corresponding provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and proceedings under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, are the second. Commercial and civil suits, where the same transaction has produced cases in two districts, are the third. Each has a different route and a different court.
Which court has the power to transfer
- Civil cases within the state. Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 allows the High Court, or the District Court, to withdraw a suit or proceeding and transfer it to another court subordinate to it. Where the High Court exercises the power, the transferee court can be any subordinate court in the state. The District Judge exercises the same power within his district, and where the suit is pending in a court subordinate to a different District Judge, the High Court is the correct forum.
- Civil cases across states. Section 25 CPC allows the Supreme Court alone to transfer a suit from a court in one state to a court in another.
- Criminal cases within the state. The High Court may transfer a criminal case from one criminal court subordinate to it to another under the corresponding provision of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (earlier Section 407 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973). The Sessions Judge may transfer within the sessions division.
- Criminal cases across states. Only the Supreme Court can do this, under the Sanhita provision corresponding to Section 406 of the old Code.
- Matrimonial petitions. Where more than one petition relating to marriage is pending, Section 21A of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 allows a party to apply to the High Court, which may transfer the petition to a court competent to try it and, if it thinks fit, order consolidation. Similar provisions exist in the Special Marriage Act, 1954 and the Indian Divorce Act, 1869.
- Consumer and tribunal matters. Transfers within the consumer commission hierarchy and before tribunals are governed by their own regulations and, in practice, by the appellate or revisional power of the body above.
What the court actually weighs
Filing a transfer petition: the sequence
- Confirm the correct forum. Identify whether the case is civil or criminal, whether the transferee court lies within the same district, and therefore whether the application lies before the District Judge, the High Court or the Supreme Court. Filing before the wrong forum costs weeks.
- Collect the case papers. Certified copies of the plaint or complaint, the order sheets showing the stage of the case, the cause title with the correct case number, and the addresses of all parties. An application that misdescribes the case number is returned.
- Draft the petition with a factual narrative. Set out the relationship between the parties, the proceedings already filed, the dates, the distance and travel involved, the witnesses who would be inconvenienced and why, and the specific prejudice that is apprehended. Attach an affidavit verifying the facts and a separate application for interim stay if the case is listed for a crucial step.
- File. In the Calcutta High Court, transfer applications on the appellate side are filed in the appropriate department with the index, the affidavit, the vakalatnama and the prescribed court fee, and are then listed before the bench assigned by the Hon'ble Chief Justice. District court applications are filed in the District Judge's court with a similar set.
- Obtain orders on service. The court usually directs notice to the respondent, with a shorter returnable date where the matter is urgent. Service is by the court's process or by the petitioner's own arrangement, depending on the order.
- Seek a stay of proceedings. Unless the court stays the proceedings in the court below, the trial continues and may reach a stage that makes transfer pointless. Ask for a stay in the petition itself, not in a separate application filed later.
- Reply, hearing and order. The respondent files a counter-affidavit, the petitioner may file a rejoinder, and the court hears arguments. The order either allows the transfer and names the transferee court, or dismisses the petition with costs.
- Transmission of records. After the order, the court below sends the record to the transferee court, and the transferee court issues fresh notice to the parties. This transmission is where delay usually creeps in, so it should be followed up rather than assumed.
Documents to file
- Transfer petition with cause title, facts, grounds and prayer.
- Affidavit in support, sworn by the applicant.
- Certified copy of the plaint or complaint in the case sought to be transferred.
- Certified copy of the order sheet showing the current stage and the next date of hearing.
- Copies of connected proceedings, if any, in other courts.
- Proof of the applicant's address, and of the respondent's address as it appears in the case records.
- Vakalatnama and the advocate's memo of appearance.
- Court fee as prescribed, and the process fee for service.
- For a matrimonial transfer, the marriage certificate or proof of marriage and particulars of any other pending petition.
- For a bias application, copies of any representation made to the District Judge or the High Court on the administrative side.
How long it takes, and what it costs
| Forum | Typical time to first listing | Time to final order | Cost factors |
|---|---|---|---|
| District Judge (within district) | A few weeks | Often 2 to 5 months | Lower court fee and travel; the fee depends on the value and nature of the case |
| Calcutta High Court, civil transfer | Two to six weeks depending on the list | Commonly 4 to 10 months if contested | High Court filing fee, per-hearing professional fee, service costs |
| Calcutta High Court, criminal transfer | Two to six weeks | Commonly 3 to 9 months | Similar to civil, plus the cost of obtaining certified copies from the trial court |
| Supreme Court, inter-state transfer | Several weeks to months | Often 8 to 18 months | Supreme Court filing, senior counsel where engaged, and travel to Delhi for hearings |
Where applicants go wrong
The most expensive mistake is filing without seeking a stay. By the time the transfer application is heard, the trial court has recorded evidence, and the transferee court must then either re-record it or proceed on the record already made. The second common mistake is pleading hardship without evidence — an applicant who says travel to Cooch Behar is impossible but has appeared at every hearing without difficulty has undermined his own case. Third, the prayer must name a court that could have tried the matter originally; a request for transfer to a court with no territorial jurisdiction will be refused.
On the responding side, the effective answers are that the application is a delaying device, that the applicant has acquiesced by participating in the proceedings for years without objection, that the inconvenience alleged is ordinary litigation inconvenience rather than exceptional hardship, and that no prejudice has been shown to the fairness of the trial. The stage of the case — particularly where it is at final arguments — is often decisive.
Can the Supreme Court transfer a case between states?
Yes, and only the Supreme Court can. A criminal case is transferred from one state to another on an application by an aggrieved party, and the Court is sparing in exercising the power, requiring material to show that a fair trial in the court seized of the matter is not possible.
Can a transfer petition be filed after evidence has begun?
Yes, there is no bar, but the court weighs delay heavily. If the case is at an advanced stage, the applicant must explain why the ground arose only then, or why earlier objection was not possible.
Does filing a transfer petition stop the trial automatically?
No. There is no automatic stay. Unless the court expressly stays proceedings in the court below, the trial continues, and hearings may be held in the applicant's absence. A specific prayer for stay, and an early application if the stay is not granted at admission, is essential.
Section 24 permits the court both to withdraw a proceeding from one court and to transfer it to another, and also to withdraw it and dispose of it itself, or send it back for trial on specified issues. In practice, most applications seek simple transfer, but the wider power is useful where a suit in a distant district could be withdrawn and tried by the High Court or a nearer court.
Can a court transfer a case on its own motion?
Under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure the High Court and the District Court may act on their own motion, though in practice they do so rarely and usually where the administrative side has noticed a problem. In criminal matters the High Court acts on an application by a party, or on a report from the court below, rather than on its own initiative.
Whether a transfer is worth filing depends on the stage of the case and the actual hardship involved, and that assessment is best made on the order sheet rather than on the client's recollection. Advocate Panchanand Shaw, practising before the Calcutta High Court from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, opposite Bankshall Court, can review the record and advise whether a transfer application is the right step or whether the same relief is better sought within the trial court.